ENTERTAINMENT
Alexander Payne Faces a Suit That Targets The Holdovers’ Afterlife
Simon Stephenson asked a judge to freeze further sales of The Holdovers, citing two reads of Frisco and a stray medical-conference line.
Simon Stephenson filed a 95-page copyright suit on October 28, 2026, asking a Los Angeles federal court to halt further sales of The Holdovers. The 95-page federal complaint names director Alexander Payne, credited writer David Hemingson, producer Mark Johnson, and the companies that still license the movie, including Focus Features, Universal Pictures Home Entertainment, and NBCUniversal Media.
Stephenson, whose credits include Pixar’s Luca and Paddington 2, says Payne read his unproduced 2013 script Frisco twice, then steered its scenes into a boarding-school Christmas film. The ask that changes the stakes is not a shared credit. He wants a judge to freeze the film’s afterlife.
A 95-Page Suit Against an Oscar Film’s Whole Chain
The case is Stephenson v. Payne, No. 2:26-cv-12615, in the Central District of California, Western Division. It demands a jury on two counts: copyright infringement against the full defendant list, and a separate claim against Payne alone under 17 U.S.C. § 1202. His lawyers are Julia B. Cherlow and Desiree Moshayedi of Bird, Marella, Rhow, Lincenberg, Drooks & Nessim, LLP.
The complaint does not claim that a grouchy adult stuck with a teenager is unique. Stephenson says his particular telling of that setup, the characters, the order of scenes, and the construction of the talk, was “meticulously transposed” into The Holdovers, “with surface cosmetic details changed.” Forty-six incidents correspond across the works, he alleges, and 24 of them land in the same order.
WHO THE COMPLAINT NAMES
| Defendant | Place in the filing |
|---|---|
| Alexander Payne | Director, alleged conduit who read Frisco twice |
| David Hemingson | Credited screenwriter and producer |
| Mark Johnson | Producer (Oscar-nominated for Best Picture) |
| Gran Via Productions LLC | Production company |
| Honest Scholar Productions, LLC | Production company |
| Miramax, LLC and Miramax Distribution Services, LLC | Production and distribution |
| Focus Features LLC | Theatrical distributor |
| Universal Pictures Home Entertainment LLC | Home video |
| NBCUniversal Media, LLC | Parent company |
Hemingson is on that list even though the complaint’s theory is that Payne carried Frisco into the room. The filing says Payne supplied the premise, redirected the story, proposed the road trip, and rewrote stretches of the script, and that the drafts Stephenson has obtained are typed in Payne’s habits rather than Hemingson’s. That is an allegation in a pleading, not a finding.
Payne Passed on Frisco Twice, Then Made a School Film
Frisco was written in 2012 and early 2013 from Stephenson’s years as a pediatrician. Thirty-nine film executives put it among their favorite unproduced screenplays, and it placed third on the 2013 Black List. The logline that circulated then described a forty-something pediatric allergist, a specialist in hazelnut, facing a divorce, who learns “lessons in living” from a terminally ill 15-year-old patient when she crashes his weekend trip to a conference in San Francisco.
The access trail is the part of the case that does not depend on taste. In August 2013, Stephenson’s camp sent the script to Payne’s producing partner, Jim Burke. An email cited in the complaint later said Payne “did like it but was not interested” in producing or directing it. Another 2013 note, from producer Tom McNulty, said Payne “loved the writing.”
In late 2019 the script came back through a different door. Producer John Woodward, working with a Netflix approach, sent Frisco to Payne again. Woodward wrote Stephenson in December 2019 that “Alexander has now read but says it is not quite what he is looking for,” and that Netflix’s interest “was predicated on Alexander.” Payne passed. Principal photography on The Holdovers began in January 2022.
FROM BLACK LIST TO DOCKET
- 2012 and early 2013: Stephenson writes Frisco as an unpublished dramatic work.
- 2013: The script places third on the Black List and is sent to Burke.
- Late 2019: Woodward submits Frisco to Payne on a Netflix track; Payne passes.
- May 6, 2021: A Holdovers draft, the complaint says, still has a student claiming he is in town “for a medical conference.”
- January 2022: Photography begins.
- March 4, 2024: The Copyright Office registers the first Frisco draft as PAU004214821, with 2012 as the year of creation.
- March 9, 2024: Stephenson’s claim becomes public, one day before the 96th Academy Awards.
- September 25, 2026: A second registration covers changes in the 2013 draft.
- October 28, 2026: The complaint is filed.
In January 2024, before the Oscar-eve leak, Stephenson took the fight to the Writers Guild of America. The guild told him it was the wrong forum for a copyright claim. Federal court is the venue he has now chosen, more than two years later.
The Line About a Medical Conference
The complaint’s most specific tell is a sentence that does not belong in a teacher movie. In Frisco, the doctor and the teenager travel to San Francisco for a medical conference. The hotel is full because of that conference, which leads them to talk through a single room and then a suite. In the May 6, 2021 draft of The Holdovers, the teenager likewise seeks a hotel room, discusses a single and then a suite, and tells the desk he is coming to town “for a medical conference.”
No medical conference figures in The Holdovers’ story: its adult protagonist is a teacher, and neither he nor the teenager is traveling to attend a medical conference. The explanation belongs to Frisco’s plot, and its presence in the May 2021 The Holdovers script is evidence that the script was unlawfully copied. Its subsequent removal, while the lines surrounding it remained, is consistent with that copying then being concealed.
Simon Stephenson, complaint, Stephenson v. Payne, filed October 28, 2026
Stephenson has three drafts: May 6, 2021, September 16, 2021, and the 2023 awards draft circulated to voters. He says earlier pages, which would tell more of the story, remain with the defendants. That is the discovery fight hiding under the plagiarism headline. A stray conference line is useful in a pleading because it is hard to wave away as a shared genre beat.
The 46-incident chart is already being flattened, in public argument, into the oldest pairing in American movies: a grouch and a smart kid. Stock pairings of that kind are not protected. The leftover conference line is the detail that does not flatten, which is why the complaint puts it in bold type and in a figure.
Why Payne Keeps Pointing at Merlusse
Payne has a different source, and he has said so on the record. Marcel Pagnol’s 1935 French film Merlusse, running 72 minutes, follows a strict, unpopular teacher left in charge of the boys who stay at boarding school over Christmas. The pupils hate him. They play tricks. On Christmas morning they find a surprise waiting, and the hated overseer looks different to them.
That is, in outline, the holiday cage of The Holdovers: Paul Giamatti’s classics teacher Paul Hunham, stuck at Barton Academy in 1970 with Dominic Sessa’s Angus Tully and Da’Vine Joy Randolph’s cook, Mary Lamb. At the Sarajevo Film Festival in August 2024, Payne called Stephenson’s claim “the stupidest thing in the world.”
That’s where I stole it from
Alexander Payne, speaking at the Sarajevo Film Festival, August 2024
He added that he did not steal it from Stephenson. The complaint quotes the line and answers it directly: admitted borrowing from Merlusse, it says, does not excuse copying Frisco. Stephenson’s lawyers do not deny that the Pagnol film and Payne’s movie share a boarding-school Christmas. They say the scene work, the trip, the third adult who tells the man to go easy on the kid, the job lost after a fight with aggrieved parents, and the closing deferred dream were taken from the hospital script, then dressed as a school.
Side by side, the complaint maps Jeff Willis, a doctor in trouble for offending a congresswoman parent, onto Hunham, a teacher in trouble for offending a senator parent. Amy, the precocious patient, becomes Angus, the precocious pupil. Valerie, a pharmaceutical representative at the conference, becomes Mary, the cook. San Francisco becomes Boston. A Beat Generation drive “to find the pearl” becomes a trip to Carthage to finish a monograph. Those are claimed correspondences. They are not a court’s findings.
Stonehaven, an Uncle, and a First Feature
Hemingson has told a third origin story, and it does not run through a children’s hospital. He wrote a television pilot about his own years at the Watkinson School in Hartford, where he spent six years as a scholarship kid after his parents split. His father was teaching there. His mother was a nurse. An uncle, Robert Hale, a World War II veteran he has called a “modern-day stoic,” is the prototype for Paul.
Payne has said he did not know that East Coast boarding-school world. He went to a Jesuit school in Omaha. He has also said he gave Hemingson a premise he had sat on for a decade and that Hemingson “did the writing” while the two of them developed “the story and the feel and the texture of it together.” The Holdovers is Hemingson’s first produced feature after 27 years in television. The complaint notes he also took a producer credit, and that the film brought him Academy Award and BAFTA nominations plus the Writers Guild Award for Original Screenplay.
On Payne’s account, then, the movie is a collision of a long-held boarding-school holiday idea, a Pagnol film, and a writer who had already put his own prep-school life on the page. On Stephenson’s account, Payne is the person who twice held Frisco, and the drafts still show his typing. Both things can be pleaded. Only one can be true in the way the complaint needs.
What an Injunction Would Freeze
The Holdovers opened in the United States on October 27, 2023, runs 2 hours 13 minutes, and has taken in $48.8 million worldwide, including $20.4 million domestic, according to Box Office Mojo. The Numbers lists a $13 million production budget. In 2026 the film was still earning in theaters: an Italian re-release added $2.85 million, a reminder that “exploitation” did not end when the Oscars did.
THE FILM THE SUIT WANTS TO PAUSE
- Theatrical haul: $48.8 million worldwide, $20.4 million in the United States and Canada.
- Awards: five Oscar nominations on March 10, 2024, with Da’Vine Joy Randolph winning supporting actress.
- Home and catalog: Universal Pictures Home Entertainment and NBCUniversal sit on the defendant list because the movie is still sold, streamed, and licensed.
- 2026 re-release: $2.85 million in Italy, booked after the original run.
Stephenson registered Frisco six days before that Oscar night. Randolph won. Hemingson did not. Giamatti did not. The public claim landed on March 9, 2024, and then sat in guild limbo until this filing.
WHAT THE PRAYER ASKS
- Money: actual damages from infringement, plus the defendants’ profits tied to it, or statutory damages.
- The freeze: a preliminary and permanent injunction, under 17 U.S.C. § 502, against further infringement, aimed at officers, licensees, and distributors.
- The personal count: statutory damages under 17 U.S.C. § 1203 on the § 1202 claim against Payne.
- Fees: costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees.
Injunctions that pull a finished, widely released movie out of stores and off platforms are rare. The complaint still asks for one. That is the pressure on Focus Features and Universal. A credit fight can be waited out. A live request to stop “licensing, marketing, promoting, and commercially exploiting” the work is a different letter to the catalog lawyers.
A Personal Claim Under a 1998 Piracy Law
The second count is aimed only at Payne. Section 1202 of the Copyright Act, added in 1998, protects the integrity of copyright management information, including a work’s title and the author’s name on copies. The complaint says each Frisco copy Payne received, the 2013 draft given to Burke and the 2019 draft sent by Woodward, carried a title page that named the work Frisco and named Stephenson as author. That title and author line, it argues, is CMI, and Payne is liable for using the work without it.
WHAT SECTION 1202 COVERS
- The term: copyright management information includes the title of a work and the name of its author, conveyed with copies of the work.
- The ban: no one may knowingly strip, alter, or traffic in that information to induce, enable, facilitate, or conceal infringement.
- The origin: Congress wrote the section for digital pirates who strip credits from copies that can be duplicated at scale.
That last point is the legal problem inside Stephenson’s extra claim. Section 1202 was built for identical copies with the credits peeled off, not for a new film that is only said to be similar. Courts have often required a showing that the later copy is the same work with the identifying information removed. A hospital script turned, on Stephenson’s own telling, into a school movie is a stretched fit for a statute aimed at file stripping. The count still puts Payne in the caption as an individual, with statutory damages that do not depend on a studio’s receipts.
No public answer from the defendants had been filed in the two days after the complaint. The medical-conference sentence is now in a federal docket, attached to a request that would reach every company still selling The Holdovers. The drafts Stephenson does not have are the ones he wants a judge to make the other side produce.
Disclaimer: This article is news reporting on a filed civil complaint and related public statements. It is informational only and is not legal advice, a prediction of how the court will rule, or an assessment of any party’s liability. Readers with a copyright, contract, or credit dispute should consult a qualified entertainment or intellectual-property attorney before acting on anything described here. Figures, docket details, and case status reflect the complaint, Box Office Mojo, The Numbers, and the other public records cited, and they may change as the defendants answer and the court issues orders.
-
NEWS3 months agoThameslink Will Pad 60,000 Ironing-Board Seats From 2027
-
HISTORY3 years agoHow Tall Was Adolf Hitler?
-
BUSINESS3 months agoU.S. Forces Clear Hormuz Mines, Then Hit Minelayers Again
-
NEWS3 months agoMicron Sells the Memory Shortage as Five-Year Contracts
-
NEWS3 months agoRoyal Caribbean Sends Los Angeles Ships to Singapore and Brisbane
-
NEWS3 months agoTwenty Controllers Closed Norwich Airport for a Bank Holiday
-
BUSINESS3 months agoSweetmore Bakeries Buys Fantasy Baking for Bar Work
-
BUSINESS3 months agoL Catterton Installs a Kraft Heinz Operator at Kettle Cuisine
