Connect with us

NEWS

Alaska’s Senate Probe Is Built to Outlast Election Night

Alaska’s U.S. attorney confirmed a Senate spoiler probe as Justice Department lawyers asked a judge to isolate same-name ballots.

Published

on

U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman confirmed on October 30 that a criminal investigation is underway over a second Dan Sullivan on Alaska’s Senate ballot. The same afternoon, Justice Department lawyers asked U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason to isolate every ballot that ranks Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. and to rule by November 2, the day before the election.

The probe and the civil case are separate files. Together they do more than publicize a same-name candidacy. They set up a way to hold and study those rankings if Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, the two-term Republican, loses to Democratic nominee Mary Peltola on November 3.

The Department Wants Those Ballots Isolated by Monday

Heyman told reporters in Anchorage that the criminal inquiry had run for several months and that recent published accounts of recruiting around Daniel J. Sullivan had brought a “significant surge of law enforcement assets to Alaska.” He would not name a statute, a target, or a charging theory. “You’re assuming that crime was committed,” he said, adding that he would not “put the cart before the horse.”

He called what investigators had seen “deeply troubling, both from a larger perspective and me as a resident of Alaska,” and asked the public to send tips to the FBI. Federal prosecutors had already sent out dozens of grand jury subpoenas and record-preservation demands. Gov. Mike Dunleavy, a Republican, ordered a separate state inquiry after the same recruiting account became public, and said the second Sullivan “is not a legitimate candidate.”

The civil track is United States v. State of Alaska, case 3:26-cv-00376-SLG, filed October 22 against the state, Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher, the election boards, and the State Ballot Counting Review Board. Peltola’s campaign committee Alaskans for Mary, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, and several civic groups later joined as intervenors. On October 30, Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward Jr. and Assistant U.S. Attorney E. Bryan Wilson asked Gleason for expedited discovery and a preliminary injunction, with a decision requested by November 2.

To guard against this danger, the United States seeks an order directing Defendants to preserve and segregate all ballots ranking Daniel J. Sullivan for the purposes of investigating whether such ranking was the product of voter confusion, should such an investigation become necessary. These modest precautionary measures will be impossible after Election Day.

Stanley E. Woodward Jr. and E. Bryan Wilson, motion, U.S. District Court for the District of Alaska

The filing also asks the court to preserve and segregate those ballots and to force fast discovery from Alaskans for Mary and the DSCC about their contacts with Daniel J. Sullivan. Attorney General Todd Blanche has said the department “does not seek to stop any ballot from being cast or to stop the certification of Alaska’s election,” and that the work is meant to keep ballots in a form Alaska officials can study. The written complaint is narrower than that reassurance, and harsher.

WHAT FRIDAY’S MOTION SEEKS

  • Ballot custody: An order that Alaska keep and set apart every ballot that ranks Daniel J. Sullivan.
  • Campaign files: Fast discovery of Alaskans for Mary’s internal and external talks about recruiting him.
  • Party files: The same demand on the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee.
  • The clock: A ruling by November 2, because Election Day is November 3.

Heyman said he had assigned several prosecutors and that the work was moving “intensely and swiftly.” He also said he had not discussed the complaints with the White House. President Donald Trump has said he told the department to file the civil case, and told a Wasilla crowd on October 13, after greeting Heyman, that ranked voting brings “damn bad cheating.”

Confusion, as the Complaint Defines It

The first amended complaint in the case, filed October 29, does not ask Gleason to pull Daniel J. Sullivan off the ballot. It asks her to treat a defined kind of Peltola win as an unlawful certification. Congress, the filing says, tasked states with protecting “the integrity of the electoral process” under 52 U.S.C. § 20501, and the Attorney General may sue for relief under § 20510(a).

Paragraph 50 of that amended complaint sets the trigger in two sentences. An election result “may be impacted by voter confusion” if both of the following are true.

THE TWO CONDITIONS IN PARAGRAPH 50

  • The first cut: Senator Sullivan does not win the election.
  • The second cut: If every vote cast for Daniel J. Sullivan had instead been cast for the senator, and Alaska’s ranked process then ran as usual, the senator would have won.
  • The ask: Do not certify that result until investigators decide whether those rankings were meant for the incumbent.

That test is a full reassignment of Daniel J. Sullivan’s support, not a review of which of his voters marked the incumbent second. Ranked voting can already move a ballot to a second choice when a first-choice candidate is eliminated. The complaint’s counterfactual is larger: treat all of those first-choice marks as if they had been the senator’s, then rerun the round. Blanche, speaking after the suit was filed, said the department is “not saying, ‘Don’t certify,’” and that a court would have to find the race was decided “because of confusion and not the will of the voters.” The complaint still writes the senator’s loss into the definition of the harm.

The same filing says aides with the DSCC introduced Jerid Kurtz, described as a specialist in quiet ballot maneuvers, to senior Peltola staff, and that the work was known inside the campaign as the Ballot Composition Project. It alleges Daniel J. Sullivan ran as a Republican “with the intention of misleading supporters of Senator Sullivan,” and that “the sole purpose of his candidacy is to benefit the Peltola campaign.” Daniel J. Sullivan has denied running at Democrats’ behest. Peltola, speaking in Juneau on October 29, said she wanted to “clear the air.”

“I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent. That is all I have ever known about,” she said. “I am not interested in tricking voters.”

How the Ballot Lists the Two Sullivans

Alaska’s clerks are not starting from a blank page. After the state’s high court kept Daniel J. Sullivan on the primary ballot, the Division of Elections released a sample that used middle initials, a party tag, and the word “Incumbent” to split the two names. The general-election ballot uses the same pair of lines. State lawyers have told Gleason that voters may also rank both men, which is the point of the ranking system.

THE TWO NAMES ON THE SENATE LINE

Candidate Ballot line Party mark
Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., Petersburg teacher Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr. None shown
Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, Republican incumbent Sullivan, Dan S. (Registered Republican) Incumbent

Daniel J. Sullivan filed for the Senate on May 29, three days before the June 1 deadline, and first asked to appear as “Dan S. Sullivan,” then corrected the request to “Dan J. Sullivan.” He sought a Republican label. Beecher, a Republican, stripped the party mark for the ballot and, in a June 15 letter later attached to the federal complaint, wrote that the “preponderance of the evidence” was that he chose the nickname and party “because that name and party affiliation happen to be the name and party affiliation of another candidate in the race.” She called a filing made “for the purpose of confusing or misleading voters” improper under Alaska Statute 15.25.060 and decertified him.

The Justice Department’s complaint adds that he used a campaign site whose layout and colors tracked the incumbent’s. That is not on the paper Alaskans mark. What is on the paper is the junior suffix, the missing party line, and the incumbent tag, which the division had not used for other incumbents in at least a decade.

A 2.5 Percent Share Already Showed Up in August

The August 18 top-four primary was the first statewide count with both Sullivans on a real ballot. Peltola finished first. The senator finished second. Daniel J. Sullivan finished third and stayed in, and a fourth-place Democrat, David Leslie, later withdrew, which moved Republican Gerald Heikes onto the November field.

THE AUGUST 18 PRIMARY

Candidate Votes Share
Mary Peltola (D) 82,244 49.5 percent
Dan S. Sullivan (R) 68,726 41.4 percent
Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. 4,107 2.5 percent
David Leslie (D), later withdrew 1,850 1.1 percent
Gerald Heikes (R), advanced after the withdrawal 1,741 1.1 percent

That 2.5 percent did not close an 8.1-point gap between Peltola and the senator in August. It did prove the name draws some first-choice support in a live count. The November race is tighter. A Rasmussen Reports survey of 775 likely voters, taken October 12-15 with a margin of error of 3 points, found Peltola at 44 percent and the incumbent at 42 percent, with Heikes at 4 percent, 3 percent for Daniel J. Sullivan, and 6 percent undecided. On second choice, 48 percent named the incumbent and 47 percent named Peltola. Cook Political Report still rated the seat a toss-up on October 30.

Apply paragraph 50’s arithmetic to those first-choice figures and the 3 percent, added in full to the senator, would move him from 42 to 45 against Peltola’s 44. That one-point swing sits inside the poll’s 3-point margin, and it is not a prediction. It is the kind of gap the complaint is written to freeze. Ranked second choices could send Daniel J. Sullivan’s ballots in more than one direction. The department’s test does not wait to see which way they go.

Heyman Recused Himself, Then Took the File Back

Heyman is not a stranger to the two senators from Alaska. He was appointed U.S. attorney for Alaska by Attorney General Pam Bondi on February 28, 2025, and sworn in on March 3, 2025, by U.S. District Judge Timothy M. Burgess. The Justice Department’s own notice listed 24 years in practice, a start as an assistant U.S. attorney in the Southern District of California in 2012, a move into the Alaska office in 2020, and a Director’s Award in 2023 for financial-crime work.

He had stepped off this matter months ago, he told reporters, because he was in talks with Sen. Sullivan and Sen. Lisa Murkowski about a judgeship. The White House nominated someone else. “The facts and the circumstances that gave rise to the initial recusal are no longer applicable,” he said. As of October 30 he was “the lead attorney on matters locally for the District of Alaska.”

That sequence puts the state’s top federal prosecutor back on a file that can affect the senator who had been discussing a judgeship with him, days before a race that can move the Senate. Heyman said the office had been working quietly on purpose and that it was not “escalating anything except to the extent that a new article came out.” He also said investigators would take election-integrity claims seriously “even if a few days before the election.”

Department Rules Say Wait Until the Race Is Certified

The Justice Manual still tells prosecutors to treat election-season publicity as a problem, not a tool. Section 9-85.000 says federal prosecutors and agents “may never select the timing of any action, including investigative steps, criminal charges, or statements, for the purpose of affecting any election, or for the purpose of giving an advantage or disadvantage to any candidate or political party.” A separate line in the same chapter is more specific about ballots.

Accordingly, the Department should not engage in overt criminal investigative measures in matters involving alleged ballot fraud until the election in question has been concluded, its results certified, and all recounts and election contests concluded. Doing otherwise runs the risk of chilling legitimate voting and campaign activities and of interjecting the investigation itself into ongoing campaigns and the adjudication of any ensuing election contest.

Justice Manual, section 9-85.000, Protection of Government Integrity

That chapter is the home of the department’s written limits on overt criminal investigative measures in ballot-fraud cases. A June 2025 note on the same page says leadership is revising the section and that the Public Integrity consultation requirement is suspended while the rewrite is underway. Blanche has separately called the informal 60-day blackout “not in writing” and “not part of the Justice Manual,” and has said the Manual’s test is improper purpose, not the calendar. Heyman’s press conference, the surge of agents, and the request to bag ranked ballots before November 3 are the calendar anyway.

Blanche has also said “never before have opponents gone to such lengths to try and thwart and cheat in an election as they’re doing in this case.” The department’s own civil papers still need Gleason to agree that a namesake already blessed by Alaska’s courts is a federal certification defect if the incumbent loses.

Alaska’s Courts Already Had This Fight

The federal docket is late on a dispute the state system closed in June. Beecher tried to keep Daniel J. Sullivan off the primary ballot. He sued. Anchorage Superior Court Judge Thomas A. Matthews vacated the exclusion on June 26, holding that a “good-faith” candidacy rule does not appear in the U.S. Constitution, Alaska election law, or the division’s own regulations. The Alaska Supreme Court, in State v. Sullivan, Case No. S-19935, left him on the ballot on June 29 and told the division it could decide how the name would be printed. The federal government did not file until October 22, after early voting had started.

Gleason noticed the lag. In an order expediting the motions to dismiss, she wrote that the United States sued “after Alaskans had already begun casting their ballots for the November 2026 election, and nearly four months after the Alaska Supreme Court directed the Division of Elections to include Daniel J. Sullivan on the ballot.” State lawyers have asked her to throw the case out as having “no legal basis.” The namesake problem, in other words, is not new to Alaska’s judges. What is new is a federal demand to keep the disputed rankings in a separate stack if the count on November 3 lands the wrong way for the incumbent.

FROM THE FILING DEADLINE TO ELECTION DAY

  1. May 29, 2026: Daniel J. Sullivan files for the Senate, three days before the June 1 deadline, and first asks to appear as Dan S. Sullivan.
  2. June 15, 2026: Beecher decertifies the filing as a bid to confuse voters.
  3. June 26, 2026: Judge Matthews orders him back onto the primary ballot.
  4. June 29, 2026: The Alaska Supreme Court affirms, and the division issues split ballot lines.
  5. August 18, 2026: He takes 4,107 votes, 2.5 percent, and advances to November.
  6. October 22, 2026: The United States files the certification suit, 12 days before Election Day.
  7. October 29, 2026: The department files the amended complaint and the two-part test.
  8. October 30, 2026: Heyman confirms the criminal probe; lawyers ask Gleason to isolate the rankings by November 2.

Alaskans will vote on November 3 for Senate and, on the same ballot, on whether to repeal ranked voting. Gleason has been asked to rule on the ballot stack the day before. If she grants the order, every ranking of Daniel J. Sullivan becomes a file the department can point to if Sen. Sullivan loses and paragraph 50’s math can be argued. If she denies it, the criminal inquiry can still run after the count. Either way, the November 3 result is no longer the last word the Justice Department is willing to accept.

Harry is the editor of BROAD BROWSE, which he owns, runs and largely writes himself as an independent publication. The site is deliberately wide, and keeping ten sections accurate with one editor depends on a rule he has followed through a decade in journalism, from reporter to editor: every section has its own primary record, and the article starts there. For business that means the filing and the earnings call transcript, for science the paper and its underlying data, for sports the official result, for auto and technology the product in his hands, for news the statement or the court document. Entertainment, lifestyle, travel and gaming get the same treatment, with the release, the itinerary or the game itself checked before writing begins. Readers come from many countries, so figures are given with context and checked before they are published. Corrections are made on the article with a dated note, and the site's corrections policy is public. He answers reader mail personally at support@broadbrowse.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending