Connect with us

NEWS

MacKinnon and Makar Exits Leave Colorado Without Its Engines

Colorado’s half-game without MacKinnon and Makar showed depth scoring and a late collapse in a 4-3 overtime loss at Ottawa.

Published

on

Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar each left Thursday’s 4-3 overtime loss at Ottawa with a lower-body injury. Colorado still scored three times after they were done and still could not close.

The Avalanche are 11-6-3 and third in the Central Division. Coach Jared Bednar said he was not sure if either star would play Saturday in Montreal, which is the lineup question. The sharper one sat in the third period they already had to play without them.

A Reverse Hit and a Four-Second Shift

The damage landed in the same period at Canadian Tire Centre. Makar, 28, took a shift at 10:44 of the second that lasted four seconds, then went down the tunnel after a non-contact sequence in which he favored his right leg. He came back for a 23-second shift that ended with 5:20 remaining and stayed on the bench after that.

MacKinnon, 31, was next. His last shift came with 8:15 left in the second, when he tried a reverse hit on Senators defenseman Artem Zub, grabbed his right side, and went to his knees. He sat for a few minutes, then limped down the tunnel. The club later said the two each sustained a lower-body injury and would not return.

Makar’s night also sat on a shorter fuse. He had left practice early on Sunday, November 8, for precaution, four days before this game, and the club still had no public word on whether Thursday was the same issue.

THE SECOND PERIOD EXITS

  1. November 8: Makar leaves practice early. Bednar calls it precaution.
  2. November 12, 10:44 of the second: Makar takes a four-second shift and heads to the locker room.
  3. November 12, 8:15 left in the second: MacKinnon grabs his right side after the Zub collision and later leaves.
  4. November 12, 5:20 left in the second: Makar’s 23-second return shift ends. He does not play again.
  5. November 12, before the third: Colorado says both are out for the rest of the night.

The ruling went out on the team account as the third period started, with no extra medical language attached.

MacKinnon leads Colorado and ranks fifth in the NHL with 30 points (10 goals, 20 assists) in 20 games, and he has averaged 20:40 a night. Makar ranks third among NHL defensemen with 23 points (five goals, 18 assists) in 19 games, at 22:54. Those are the minutes Bednar meant when he talked about running without a couple of horses for half the game.

Colorado Still Found Three Goals Without Them

Ottawa already led 2-0 when the stars went down. Shane Pinto opened at 7:11 of the first, and Tim Stutzle made it 2-0 at 13:13. The Avalanche then battled back from being down 2-0 with MacKinnon and Makar in the room, which is the part of the night the panic posts skipped.

Artturi Lehkonen cut it to 2-1 at 18:04 of the second on the power play, his 14th goal, from Nazem Kadri and T.J. Hughes. Parker Kelly tied it at 3:54 of the third shorthanded, his fourth, off a rush after he picked off a pass. Gabriel Landeskog put Colorado in front 3-2 at 10:03 of the third, also on the power play, his eighth, from Brock Nelson and Devon Toews.

COLORADO GOALS AFTER BOTH STARS LEFT

Time Scorer Type
18:04, 2nd Artturi Lehkonen Power play
3:54, 3rd Parker Kelly Shorthanded
10:03, 3rd Gabriel Landeskog Power play

Special teams carried that comeback. Colorado scored twice on the power play, went 5-for-5 on the penalty kill, and got Kelly’s short-handed goal. Toews’ helper on Landeskog’s goal also tied him with John-Michael Liles at 275 points, third among defensemen in franchise history.

The finish was the other half of the same sample. Drake Batherson tied it at 16:04 of the third after Jordan Spence’s shot trickled through Scott Wedgewood. In overtime, Kelly threw a blind pass into the middle of the zone, Pinto stepped into it, and he beat Wedgewood from the slot at 2:08. Linus Ullmark, back after nine games out, stopped 26 shots. Wedgewood stopped 22 on 26. Shots finished 29-26 for Colorado.

So the supporting cast can score at even a 2-0 deficit. It also gave the lead back with four minutes left and then handed Pinto the winner. That is the dual-absence tape, not a hypothetical.

The 121-Point Season This Is Not

Last season Colorado went 55-16-11, took the Presidents’ Trophy with a franchise-record 121 points, and led the league in wins, points, regulation wins, goals, and goals against. MacKinnon won the Rocket Richard Trophy with 53 goals and put up 127 points in 80 games at 22:16 a night. Makar had 79 points in 75 games at 24:51. Landeskog, back in the lineup after years away, was in the middle of that club.

This group is 25 points through 20 games, seven behind the Minnesota Wild at 14-3-4 and 32 points, and it already has six regulation losses. The road record is 4-5-1. A point in Ottawa made it four straight games with at least one (2-0-2), which Bednar called a big point against a good team. It did not look like last November, when this franchise went 11-0-2.

LAST SEASON AND THIS ONE

  • 2025-26 record: 55-16-11, 121 points, first in the NHL.
  • 2026-27 through 20 games: 11-6-3, 25 points, third in the Central.
  • MacKinnon then and now: 22:16 a night and 127 points last season; 20:40 and 30 points through 20 games.
  • Makar then and now: 24:51 a night and 79 points in 75 games last season; 22:54 and 23 points through 19 games.

Colorado has almost no recent regular-season tape of losing both at once. The club went 4-2-1 without Cale Makar in 2025-26 and 2-0-0 without Nathan MacKinnon in the same season. Those were separate absences. Thursday was the first time this group had to play a full period, then overtime, with both engines parked.

MacKinnon, taken first overall in 2013, has 1,172 points (430 goals, 742 assists) in 970 games and won the Calder Trophy in 2013-14 and the Hart Trophy in 2024. Makar, taken fourth overall in 2017, has 530 points (141 goals, 389 assists) in 489 games, the 2019-20 Calder, and two Norris Trophies. Bednar can next-man-up the language. He cannot next-man-up 20:40 and 22:54.

Manson Already Left a Hole on the Blue Line

If Makar sits, the problem is not only who runs the power play. Josh Manson has been out since he hurt an ankle on October 28 against New Jersey, and Bednar said about eight weeks. Colorado moved him to long-term injured reserve on November 9 so it could recall defenseman Alex Gagne. Noah Juulsen had already been taking the extra seat.

That is the blue line Makar would be leaving, not the one that closed last spring. Toews is already at 21:09 a night. Brett Kulak, Sam Malinski, Brent Burns, and Juulsen are the next names, and none of them replaces a 22:54 all-situations defenseman who also runs the breakout. Up front, Martin Necas (24 points), Lehkonen, Kadri, Landeskog, Nelson, and Jaden Schwartz have to cover MacKinnon’s 20:40 if he is out.

WHO ABSORBS THE MINUTES

  • On defense: Toews already logs 21:09, with Kulak, Malinski, Burns, and Juulsen next if Makar sits.
  • Up front: Necas, Lehkonen, Kadri, Landeskog, Nelson, and Schwartz have to cover MacKinnon’s shifts and the first power play.
  • Already gone: Manson is on long-term injured reserve after the eight-week ankle timeline Bednar gave on October 30.

The third period in Ottawa was a short version of that chart. Kelly, Lehkonen, and Landeskog scored. Burns had a shot blocked on the play that became Pinto’s first goal. Juulsen broke his stick trying to stop that same rush. The names who have to take the extra turns already had their fingerprints on both the comeback and the holes.

Will MacKinnon and Makar Play Against Montreal?

Bednar had no medical update after the game and said he did not know if either player would be in the lineup Saturday against the Canadiens at 5 p.m. MST. Both are expected to travel. Montreal, which pushed a point streak to 12 with a win over Boston, is the next stop on a four-game trip that started in Toronto, continued in Ottawa, and ends Wednesday at the Utah Mammoth.

WHAT WE KNOW

  • The injuries: Both are listed as lower body, and neither returned after the second period in Ottawa.
  • The next date: Colorado plays at Montreal on Saturday, November 14, then at Utah on Wednesday.
  • Makar’s week: He left practice on November 8 as a precaution before Thursday’s exit.

WHAT IS UNCONFIRMED

  • Severity: The club has not said how long either player might miss, or if Makar’s two issues are related.
  • Saturday’s lineup: Bednar would not commit to MacKinnon or Makar against the Canadiens.

Landeskog, who scored the 3-2 goal, treated it as a roster night rather than a referendum. “Obviously, they’re two of the best players in the world, so you like to have them, no doubt,” he said. “But I don’t think it’s any different, right? Like you just play with whoever you got, whoever’s ready to go, whoever’s healthy and up. They play. So, hope those guys will be just fine.”

He also owned the close. “We kind of ended up in a hole to start, and we fought and dug our way out of it. Obviously, you have a lead with four minutes to go. We’d like to be able to close it out, but it goes in overtime and they end up winning.”

A Point on the Road, Then the Rest of the Trip

Bednar kept the night in that same frame: a point on the road, a good opponent, and two missing horses.

It’s a good hockey team we played, and you’re running without a couple of horses, you know, for half the game. So, pretty gutsy effort from our group. I’ll take it.

Jared Bednar, Avalanche coach, after the loss in Ottawa

The Senators moved to 12-6-2. Colorado kept the extra point and flew on with the same two questions it had when the third period started: who plays in Montreal, and how long the depth has to look like this. The 4-3 tape already gave a partial answer. The next one comes Saturday.

Harry is the editor of BROAD BROWSE, which he owns, runs and largely writes himself as an independent publication. The site is deliberately wide, and keeping ten sections accurate with one editor depends on a rule he has followed through a decade in journalism, from reporter to editor: every section has its own primary record, and the article starts there. For business that means the filing and the earnings call transcript, for science the paper and its underlying data, for sports the official result, for auto and technology the product in his hands, for news the statement or the court document. Entertainment, lifestyle, travel and gaming get the same treatment, with the release, the itinerary or the game itself checked before writing begins. Readers come from many countries, so figures are given with context and checked before they are published. Corrections are made on the article with a dated note, and the site's corrections policy is public. He answers reader mail personally at support@broadbrowse.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending